Book vs. Movie: Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone

I’ve never met a movie I like more than the book.  When it comes to Harry, I love them both – but there are a lot of details left out if you only see the movie.  Here are some, from Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone.
The movie starts out with Dumbledore on the Dursley’s street.  In the book, we actually get a glimpse at Vernon Dursley as he goes through his morning routine, getting to work, yelling at people, etc. before any of the magic stuff happens.
And when it comes to Dumbledore, he’s a lot goofier in the books than in the movies.  Wears purple robes and high-heeled boots.  Makes everyone sing the Hogwarts school song, but to their own tune, and says thinks like “I haven’t blushed so much since Madam Pomfrey told me she liked my new earmuffs,” and that he has a scar on his knee that is a perfect map of the London underground.  What??
In the book and movie, Hagrid shows up carrying baby Harry on a flying motorcycle.  In the book, he says that he borrowed the bike from young Sirius Black…who isn’t mentioned again until (and then is, of course, a main character in) book number 3.  Genius.  Hagrid, in the book, is far larger than he is in the movie – “twice as tall as a normal man, and five times as wide”.  And he knows how to spell in the books (vs. “Happee Birthdae Harry” on the cake in the movie).
In the book, Dudley’s friend Piers goes to the zoo with the Dursley’s for Dudley’s birthday.  Harry isn’t supposed to go, but his babysitter, Ms. Figg falls and breaks her leg (another character who becomes key in later books – book 5, for her).
In the book, once letters from Hogwarts start coming to Harry addressed to the cupboard under the stairs, the Dursley’s move him into Dudley’s 2nd bedroom.  The letters also show up in crazy places – for example, inside eggs Petunia brings home from the grocery.
In the movie Hagrid tells Harry he’s not allowed to do magic, and that is all that is said.  In the book, he elaborates – Hagrid was thrown out of Hogwarts and had his wand snapped in half (which Harry figures, is now a part of the umbrella he always carries).  Of course, we find out why he was thrown out in book 2.
In the movie, Hagrid takes Harry to the train station straight from shopping at Diagon Alley.  In the book, he goes back to the Dursley’s for a month (after all, his birthday is July 31, and there is still a month of summer left).  The Dursley’s get a good laugh as they leave Harry at the train station, completely lost as to where platform 9 and 3/4 is.In the book, Harry has his first run-in with Malfoy when getting fitted for robes at Madam Malkin’s.  It is then that Draco gives Harry his first clue that he doesn’t want to be in Slytherin.  Harry and Ron have their first face-off with Malfoy, Crabbe and Goyle on the train.  In the movie, he doesn’t meet them till they’re at Hogwarts.
In the book, Quirrell is the one who clues Harry into the reason Snape dislikes him so – that Snape and his father were enemies in school.  If you’ve only watched the moive, you wouldn’t have any idea why Snape hates Harry.
The discovery of Nicholas Flamel…in the movie, all of a sudden Hermione has a book, and says “Of course!  Nicholas Flamel…blah blah blah.”  Of course?  What?  There is no explanation of how she knows all of a sudden!  In the book, Harry first reads Flamel’s name on Dumbledore’s chocolate frog card, but then he can’t remember where he’s read it.  It’s not until they’re eating chocolate frogs again after Christmas that it comes back to him, and they realize, since Flamel is 600 and some years old, they need to look in old books, vs. the modern ones they had been perusing.
In the movie, we meet Norbert when he hatches and never see him again.  Hagrid mentions that Dumbledore sends Norbert to Romania.  In the book, he wrecks havoc on Hagrid’s cabin as he gets bigger, and the three finally convince Hagrid to let Ron’s brother Charlie’s friends take him to Romania.  Harry and Hermione sneak the dragon to the top of a Hogwarts tower for the friends to pick him up, and this is when they, and Malfoy, get caught and sent to detention with Hagrid.  Ron is in the hospital wing when this happens in the book, and never gets in trouble or goes into the dark forest – however, Neville does.
In the movie, Harry, Hermione and Ron only have to get past Fluffy, through the room with the flying keys, and the chess game before Harry gets to the final room with Quirrell.  In the book, there are two more challenges – a troll, which has already been knocked out when the three get to him, and a set of potions by Snape, along with a riddle that they must figure out in order to know which to drink to go on.  Harry and Hermione (well really, Hermione) figure this out; Ron is laying passed out on the chess board.
In the book, Dumbledore tells Harry “Fear of a name only increases fear of the thing itself.”  These words are spoken by Hermione in the second movie, and not at all in the first.  In the movie, Voldemort is the one who tells Harry “There is only power, and those too weak to seek it.”  In the book, it is Quirrell.

One response to “Book vs. Movie: Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone

  1. So much differences, can’t believe I never really noticed them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: